Coppock, Alexander (2014). Information Spillovers: Another Look at Experimental Estimates of Legislator Responsiveness. Journal of Experimental Political Science, 1, pp 159-169. doi: 10.1017/xps.2014.9

Coppock, A. (2016) ‘“Information Spillovers: Another Look at Experimental Estimates of Legislator Responsiveness”—CORRIGENDUM’, Journal of Experimental Political Science, 3(2), pp. 206–208. doi: 10.1017/XPS.2016.8

Corrigendum

In Coppock (2014), I presented a reanalysis of Butler and Nickerson (2011), a field experiment that tested the effects of providing state legislators district-level public opinion data on their roll call votes for a bill. The reanalysis employed a method introduced by Bowers, Fredrickson, and Panagopoulos (2013) to conclude that the Butler and Nickerson estimate of the total effect of treatment was biased downward; when spillovers were accounted for, the total effect of treatment was estimated to be nearly twice as large.

Due to a coding error, the results presented in Figures 2 and 3 of Coppock (2014) were incorrect. The similarity matrix I used falsely implied that all legislators were equally close to one another in ideological space. When corrected, the uncertainty attending to the estimates of the indirect effects of information as transmitted via the Ideological Similarity spillover model is larger. In light of these updated results, I revise my conclusions regarding the transfer of information within the New Mexico state legislature during this experiment. There is insufficient statistical evidence to conclude that indirect exposure to information altered legislator behavior.

Abstract

A field experiment carried out by Butler and Nickerson (Butler, D. M., and Nickerson, D. W. (2011). Can learning constituency opinion affect how legislators vote? Results from a field experiment. Quarterly Journal of Political Science 6, 55–83) shows that New Mexico legislators changed their voting decisions upon receiving reports of their constituents’ preferences. The analysis of the experiment did not account for the possibility that legislators may share information, potentially resulting in spillover effects. Working within the analytic framework proposed by Bowers et al. (2013), I find evidence of spillovers, and present estimates of direct and indirect treatment effects. The total causal effect of the experimental intervention appears to be twice as large as reported originally.

Figure

Corrected figure from corrigendum, comparing estimates as originally reported and corrected.

Coppock (2014) Corrected Figure 3

Bibtex citation

@article{coppock2016informationspillovers,
title = "“Information Spillovers: Another Look at Experimental Estimates of Legislator Responsiveness”—CORRIGENDUM",
doi = "10.1017/XPS.2016.8",
publisher = "Cambridge University Press",
address = "New York, USA",
author = "Alexander Coppock",
volume = "3",
number = "2",
pages = "206-208",
year = "2016",
month = "001",
day = "001",
journal = "Journal of Experimental Political Science"
}